SCENE OPENS on Mr. Jennings (Steve Holmes), who answers his door. Michelle (Naomi Swann) stands there. She looks nervous and reluctant. Ah, Michelle! Mr. Jennings says with a pleasant smile. Come in, please, he says. Michelle enters the house wordlessly. ‘SO glad you’re here. I can’t TELL you how much I appreciate you coming!’ Mr. Jennings says brightly. ‘Well… it’s not like you gave me much of a choice,’ Michelle says, an edge of contempt in her voice. ‘Oh come on now Michelle, I’m only your TEACHER. I can’t control what you do!
After a moment, Holly (Emily Willis) comes into the living room. Hi! She must be Michelle? Holly says enthusiastically. Yeah…hi, Michelle says, smiling. Ready to get started? Holly asks. Um, yeah, sure, and…and thanks again for doing this, Michelle says. ‘Yeah of course! Dad’s never asked me to tutor one of his students before, so I hope I do ok!’ Holly says with a little chuckle, taking a seat next to Michelle at the table. ‘Oh, I’m sure you’ll do GREAT honey,’ Mr. Jennings says in a sickly-sweet tone. Thanks, Dad, Holly says happily. Mr. Jennings is about to walk out of the room but turns back. ‘And be good, you two!’ he says seemingly jokingly. ‘Don’t worry about us, Dad,’ Holly laughs. ‘Oh I’m not worried. In fact, I think the two of you are going to get along…JUST FINE,’ he says with a smile, but a hint of something darker, something…unknown lurks under his grin.
CUT TO TITLE
As Holly shows Michelle something on a shared paper, circling something with a pen, she pauses and looks up at Michelle. So…what’s it like having him as a teacher? Holly asks, sincerely curious. ‘Your dad? Well, he’s um, he’s…’ Michelle says, seemingly unsure of how to answer as she glances at the room’s entranceway. We don’t see what she’s looking at. Actually he’s her STEP-dad, Holly clarifies. Oh…she didn’t know that, Michelle says. Yeah, he married her mom a few years back, Holly responds. ‘I’m 18 now, so I guess it was about…3 years ago?’ Holly muses aloud. Oh ok, that’s cool, Michelle says noncommittally. But, her mom died last year, so…now it’s just the two of them, Holly says, a hint of sadness in her voice. Oh, she’s…she’s so sorry, Michelle says sincerely. That’s ok, Holly says, snapping back to her bubbly self. So? What IS he like as a teacher? Holly presses. Um…Michelle says, fidgeting nervously. She glances again at the room’s entranceway warily, but Holly doesn’t seem to notice the look. We now see what Michelle is looking at: Mr. Jennings, who is spying into the room, unbeknownst to his daughter. When Michelle glances at him, they lock eyes and he gives her a glare through gritted teeth. He’s…he’s really nice, Michelle says finally. Holly laughs. ‘Don’t worry, you can say it,’ Holly says. S-say what? Michelle asks cautiously. That he’s a goof, Holly laughs. With all his corny sayings and cheesy jokes, Holly says. Oh…yeah, Michelle says, giving a phony laugh and glancing again at the living room entranceway. Aware that Mr. Jennings is watching, Michelle becomes slightly flirty with Holly. Mr. Jennings watches impatiently.
Michelle begins to seduce Holly as Mr. Jennings watches with increasing pleasure. The seduction is successful and Michelle leans in to kiss Holly. Holly returns her kiss tentatively, but as she gets swept up and lost in the moment, Holly kisses Michelle back with increasing passion. From the room’s entranceway, we see Mr. Jennings. His eyes are lit up as he watches, licking his lips.
Swept up in the moment, the girls makeout increases in intensity as Mr. Jennings watches, fondling himself over his pants. Realizing she got carried away, Holly stops the makeout and rushes out of the room in embarrassment, running into her father. Holly realizes that he saw the whole thing. To her shock, Mr. Jennings reveals that he caught Michelle dealing on school property and she agreed to seduce Holly in exchange for his silence.
Holly is disgusted, but not wanting Michelle’s life to be ruined, agrees to continue. Holly and Michelle begin to kiss again, tentatively and nervously. No…he’s seen THIS already, let’s move this along, Mr. Jennings says impatiently. ‘Take off her clothes…and do it SLOWLY,’ Mr. Jennings says to Michelle. Angry and disgusted, Michelle starts to take off Holly’s clothes. Holly continues to be nervous, but Michelle tries to calm her down, leading her through the humiliating experience. Michelle begins to eat Holly’s pussy. Holly seems ashamed that her dad is watching, but can’t help but enjoy it. After a while, Mr. Jennings says ‘now it’s YOUR turn, sweetie,’ and directs Holly to eat Michelle’s pussy.